
SHANGHAI DECLARATION
REPORT TO INCP
16
OCTOBER 2004
(INCD delegation to INCP meeting: Korkor Amarteifio, Leonardo Brant, Jacques Béhenzin, Garry Neil and Danny Yung.)
INCD
is a worldwide network of individuals and organisations in the cultural sector
working to counter the adverse effects of economic globalisation on arts and
culture. INCD
has more than 300 members in 71 countries, a number of which are international
organisations with a presence in other countries. Our scope is truly global.
INCD has organized a parallel meeting to the
INCP meetings for the past five years.
This week, the newly elected Steering Committee of the INCD, comprising 19 people from 18 countries, met to
review all of the issues we are facing.
On October 13, we were privileged to be joined by 29 representatives of
Chinese civil society and a number of observers from other countries to discuss
tri-sector collaboration, cultural development, the theme Traditional
Cultures and Modernisation as well as cultural economics. Our agenda for the day was framed together
with our Chinese partners.
Convention on the Protection of the Diversity of
Cultural Contents and Artistic Expressions
We find ourselves at a historic moment. Last year, UNESCO launched the project to
conclude a Convention on the protection of the diversity of cultural
contents and artistic expressions. This
is a turning point in the global debate on the role of culture for sustainable
development and the human condition.
Countries of the world have a window of opportunity to agree on a
binding global framework that will recognize the right of governments to
protect their cultural identities and to promote cultural diversity through
appropriate policies. Given the background
of global trade negotiations, it is crucially important for the Convention to
be adopted in 2005, since it will establish as a global principle that cultural
goods and services are like no others.
INCD congratulates INCP for its efforts, the
INCP has played a key role in putting this issue onto the international agenda.
The INCD
was an active participant in the recent Intergovernmental Meeting of Experts in
Paris and we
were delighted to see representatives from 132 countries meeting for the
purpose of negotiating a Convention. At
the meeting, INCD welcomed the Draft
put forward by the UNESCO secretariat as a good basis on which to begin the
negotiations between governments. In two
of our interventions, we were requested formally by the NGO-UNESCO Liaison Committee
to speak on behalf of numerous organizations maintaining formal relations with
UNESCO.
INCD observed that there was an uneven level
of understanding among government delegations about the fundamental purpose of
the Convention. Given the challenges
this presents, we believe it is important for the INCP members to work together
at UNESCO in the coming period and to take a leadership role in that forum.
We continue to support the need for a timely and
effective Convention. To achieve its
objectives, we believe the language of the Convention must be adjusted. Since we share many of these perspectives
with INCP, we invite your governments to consider submitting our
proposals into the UNESCO process. Our
submissions to UNESCO are based on the following fundamental objectives:
- The status of the Convention must be
equivalent to the trade agreements.
Neither option provided in Article 19 of the Draft meets that
objective.
- The Convention must be an effective
tool for countries of the South to develop their creative capacity and
cultural industries consistent with other UNESCO instruments that
recognize and promote the integral relationship of culture and
development.
- The Convention must acknowledge the
broad scope of policy tools that are used to promote cultural diversity
and the right of governments to adapt and adopt new ones in the coming
years to respond to technological developments and changing circumstances
and needs.
INCD will submit a formal intervention by the
November 15 UNESCO deadline. In response
to the Paris discussions, we will amend our earlier submission by further
strengthening the provisions we have put forward about Articles 19, 13 and 21
which deal with the relationship of this Convention to existing treaties and
agreements and by proposing changes to ensure that all government policies that
directly or indirectly affect culture are covered fully by the Convention
provisions.
We also believe the text must provide for the adjudication of disputes
where both states are parties to the Convention, a system that permits a
member to seek an opinion where a dispute exists with a state that is not a
party to the Convention and an ability for individuals of a state party who are
entitled to enjoy the protections of this Convention to raise concerns about
non-compliance. We will also call on
governments to ensure that the follow-up mechanisms have sufficient resources
to carry out the tasks assigned to them.
Meanwhile, it is
vital for all of us to continue to work to ensure that governments refrain from
making commitments in bilateral and multilateral trade talks that would affect
their ability to implement or change cultural policies. In particular, we must all be vigilant about
the recent decisions of the WTO to reinvigorate talks on the General Agreement
on Trade in Services within the framework of the Doha Round of negotiations
Finally, we note
our concern about the emerging role of the WTO in the development of the
Convention. We understand that there
will soon be a series of meetings of the WTO in Geneva to determine its position on the
Convention, in which government trade representatives will be
participating. It is critical for
Ministers of Culture to use their competence in the cultural arena to frame
their government’s position and as a basis for their representations at the WTO.
Traditional Cultures and Modernisation
We had a rich exchange of views with our Chinese
friends and colleagues on this theme.
Our collaboration with representatives of Chinese civil society will
continue as we both work to promote cultural diversity and to support
threatened languages and cultures including those of indigenous peoples.
We understand that modernisation is significantly
about development and technology and while these processes are often a threat
to the survival of traditional cultures, we do not believe this is an
inevitable result. Traditional cultures
and their knowledge can contribute greatly to the modernisation process and we
must work together to ensure this happens, through supporting these cultures,
developing the necessary regimes to protect legally their Traditional Knowledge
and other measures. Technology can also
be an instrument for promoting the development of traditional cultures and
advancing cultural diversity.
INCD and our Chinese colleagues understand
that while governments and the private sector often measure development and
modernisation strictly in economic terms, the most fundamental measurement must
be surely the humanity of societies. We
need to ensure that development projects respect local cultures and that
development of their creative capacity and cultural industries becomes an
integral part of sustainable development.
We note that the Convention can provide new models for cooperation for
development and the INCD proposal
for specific market access provisions is one such model.
In concluding our joint session, Chinese and
international delegates agreed that the Government of the People’s Republic of
China can play a key role in the process of developing the Convention on the
protection of the diversity of cultural contents and artistic expressions
and we look forward to collaboration. China
has a powerful and growing economy, a vibrant culture and a policy based on the
principles of sustainable development that could be useful to others.
INCD Work Plan
The Shanghai
event was the Fifth Annual Meeting of the INCD
and we approved an ambitious work plan for the next year. In addition to working on the Convention and
trade issues, we intend to move forward with our next major campaign –
advocating that development agencies allocate an appropriate and fixed
percentage of their resources to cultural projects. We will also work to find ways to ensure that
cultural impact assessment becomes a fully integrated part of sustainable development
indicators. Finally, INCD will launch a discussion of how cultural
diversity could be promoted by strengthening cultural rights established by
various international instruments. We
look forward to learning about the future plans of the INCP beyond the
necessary focus on the UNESCO Convention.
Our agenda of meetings will include a national
meeting in the United States
and regional meetings in Latin America, Francophone Africa, Europe and the Caribbean. We have
plans for other meetings that are contingent on finding the resources. As INCD
members continue to work on a local and national level we look forward to close
collaboration with our respective culture ministers.
We will organize the Seventh Annual INCD Conference in Senegal in 2005 in collaboration
with the next INCP meeting. The
provisional theme of our Conference will be Cultural Diversity and Development.
Future of the INCP
Since it is finally being recognized that culture is
a life-defining issue, we believe it is critically important for the world’s
culture ministers to establish the INCP as its united front for taking a
proactive role in the global debates. We
are excited to see the expansion of the INCP in the past year and understand
this brings opportunities and challenges.
We look forward to finding ways to collaborate on the full range of
issues that we are addressing. We will
continue to engage with other ministers as well since the issues around which
we are working to promote, develop and preserve cultural diversity extend
broadly.
We urge culture ministers to engage with officials in
trade and finance and with representatives at the WTO in Geneva to ensure that their interventions
reflect INCP positions on the UNESCO Convention. We hope that Geneva-based representatives of
INCP members will advocate collectively in the WTO for an effective and timely Convention.